Anti-ICE Nativity Displays Protest Trump’s Policies on Immigration
Nativity Scenes as Protest Art Against ICE Policies
Amidst the backdrop of ongoing immigration controversies in the United States, nativity scenes with humanitarian messages are emerging as powerful protest art. Despite pushback from right-wing leaders and religious authorities, communities across the nation are redefining traditional holiday displays to reflect contemporary social issues.
The “ICE WAS HERE” Nativity
St. Susanna Parish in Dedham, Massachusetts, has recently been at the center of national attention due to its provocative nativity scene. Instead of the Holy Family, the scene displays a sign saying “ICE WAS HERE,” highlighting the impact of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) activities in the area. The inclusion of the LUCE defense hotline further emphasizes the parish’s stance on immigrant rights. Despite requests from the Archdiocese of Boston to remove the display, citing the inappropriate use of sacred objects for political messaging, the nativity remains pending review.
National Trends in Nativity Protest Art
Other churches have followed suit, using their nativity scenes to critique the current administration’s immigration policies. Urban Village Church in Chicago prominently displays a sign reading, “Due to ICE activity in our community, the Holy Family is in hiding.” Similarly, Lake Street Church in Evanston features a nativity with Mary, Joseph, and a zip-tied baby Jesus surrounded by Roman centurions styled as ICE agents. Reverend Michael Woolf of Lake Street Church has expressed hope that these displays will encourage reflection on the scriptures within today’s context.
Historical Context and Right-Wing Responses
These modern interpretations have historical roots in protest art, challenging right-wing discourse that claims such displays politicize religious occasions. Previous nativity scenes, like the one at Claremont United Methodist Church in 2019 showing the Holy Family in cages, have sparked dialogue about the moral implications of immigration detention policies.
The Catholic Church’s Stance
Despite controversies, the Catholic Church has taken a stand against harsh immigration policies. The United States Conference of Catholic Bishops has criticized mass deportations and emphasized respect for immigrants. Pope Leo XIV recently condemned the treatment of migrants in the U.S., aligning with the message conveyed by these protest nativities.
The nativity scenes symbolize resistance and hope, urging viewers to reflect on the plight of the displaced and advocating for a message of compassion during the holiday season.